Comic Should Be Good just finished their Superhero March Madness, where comic fans voted on which characters would win a fight. The rules were: the characters know which fight is coming, have a half hour to get ready, and have to use their normal resources. Reading through the posts after each voting and results round made me sad. Not sad because my favorite fictional characters lost matches based on the outcome of random internet fan voted results concerning pretend contests between imaginary people with impossible powers, mind you. Incensed, and filled with nerd rage maybe, but not sad. (And not nearly as upset as my mother, it's apparently genetic.) What made me sad was how many different comments in the voting threads said, “I can’t imagine character A EVER beating character B.”
Really???
In fictional worlds where huge personal tragedy and huge doses of radiation produce not a major need for counseling and a major case of death, but people with powers, abilities, and drive far beyond the norms, who choose to wear funny pajamas and fight crime: you can’t imagine something.
In a story setting, where what any sane person would call “surpassing insurmountable odds” is called “Wednesday”: you CAN’T imagine something.
In a medium where Doctor Doom has fallen to Squirrel Girl and Robin II defeated Mongul (in the arctic, wearing a polo shirt and a green scaly version of “tighty whiteys”; the same costume Robin I survived forty four North Eastern winters in): YOU CAN’T IMAGINE SOMETHING?
I weep for some of my fellow fans. After all the comics I’ve read, I could readily imagine Galactus being trounced by Perry the Platypus.
Therefore, I would like to share some of my imagination.